Skip Navigation
It had been determined Ramirez would separately be tried due to the fact expected ringleader associated with criminal activity. The rest of the three could be tried together.

It had been determined Ramirez would separately be tried due to the fact expected ringleader associated with criminal activity. The rest of the three could be tried together.

Rivera recalls their sex being truly a big element of jury selection, with 50 % of possible jurors increasing their hand when expected should they had been uncomfortable with homosexuality. The ladies had been told that their sex wasn’t allowed to be a element when you look at the studies, but homophobia is at the forefront of both.

“At the start of my test, the prosecutor painted the image towards the jury,” Ramirez remembers. “They stated, ‘Close your eyes, imagine a lesbian feminine compromising her nieces to her buddies and holding them down, and doing all of these what to them.’ Needless to say into the jury’s mind, they’re wanting to visualize it, plus it’s horrible. That is their aunt, someone who’s designed to be loving and care for them. And here this woman is compromising them with their lesbian buddies.”

She claims throughout her test, they over and over noticed that she ended up being homosexual, and insinuating so it means she had been with the capacity of the criminal activity, and that’s why her victims had been feminine. The exact same arguments had been mentioned within the 2nd test.

“They didn’t desire to tune in to whatever else which was happening included in the allegations. Simply because regarding the reality because we were gay,” Ramirez recalls that it was four lesbian women, and we’re Hispanic and poorit was all.

In 1997, she had been convicted and sentenced to 37 and a half years. The remaining three ladies were convicted in 1998 and sentenced to 15 years each. Appeals failed, plus they had been locked up in the summertime of 2000.

All four ladies had been place in different devices, and after seven years together, Vasquez and Rivera had been torn aside. For the couple of months, they might compose to one another, nevertheless the jail stopped permitting this, Rivera claims. Without any real method to communicate, their relationship fizzled without closure. It will be over 10 years prior to the females would experience freedom once more.

A path that is slow freedom

Letters to different purity tasks weren’t assisting. But Darrell Otto, a data that are canadian, came across the outcome. He did research, corresponded with all the women, and had been confounded because the case didn’t fit with any understood patterns of feminine intimate offenders, which are uncommon to start with.

Otto contacted Debbie Nathan during the nationwide Center for factor and Justice, a nonprofit that will help people wrongly accused of crimes against young ones, whom then reached away to Deborah Esquenazi, an LGBTQ filmmaker. Nathan shared with her in regards to the San Antonio Four, and even though initially skeptical, Esquenazi came across aided by the ladies and very quickly became specialized in telling their tale.

Rivera says she had been uncertain about talking publicly, considering that the news had formerly portrayed her friends like Satan-worshipping monsters, but after sitting yourself down with Esquenazi, she could inform the filmmaker had been the perfect individual to inform their side of this tale.

Esquenazi interviewed all the females and cut together a film that is short the injustices of the instance, concentrating on the tragic separation of Vasquez and Rivera. She shared the movie every-where she could, and individuals began observing, including Rosie Gonzalez.

Gonzalez, a prominent attorney that is gay present judicial prospect in San Antonio, ended up being really contacted years prior by Vasquez’s present gf, who was simply seeking aid in raising knowing of the scenario. But since Gonzalez is targeted on family members law and youngster welfare legislation litigation, perhaps perhaps maybe not criminal legislation, she ended up being not able to help and suggested they contact the Innocence venture.

A couple of years later on, Gonzalez is at a meeting for Allgo, an LGBTQ Latino company in Austin, where Esquenazi had been here assessment the film that is short. Gonzalez discovered it absolutely was the exact same females she’d learned about years before. After learning more info on the injustices these females experiencedand experiencing like her occupation had let these women downshe offered Esquenazi any assistance she required. Gonzalez assisted host tests of this movie, which gained the eye for the Innocence Project of Texas.

They started working the truth and discovered a retired detective who had held all of the instance files. Esquenazi and also the Innocence venture of Texas couldn’t manage to replicate the many bins of records, so Gonzalez let them spend days in her own workplace utilizing her copier, paper, and ink at no cost. While she’d never ever met the ladies, Gonzalez wished to assist their cause however she could.

Then, Vasquez ended up being unexpectedly released on parole in 2012. Things quickly started dropping into location for the remaining women. The exact same 12 months, one of several Limon girls recanted her allegations on digital digital digital camera to Esquenazi, saying absolutely nothing had really occurred; that her daddy and grandmother had coerced her sis into result in the accusations.

Additionally, a fresh study that is medical discovered that numerous forensic technology techniques, like the one Dr. Kellogg had used to spot sexual assault, lacked foundation that is scientific. In 2013, Dr. Kellogg finalized an affidavit saying that her testimony that is previous was inaccurate since technology had changed.

In light associated with findings that numerous forensic technology methods had been not any longer reliable, a Texas bill was passed away that aided people challenge beliefs made on which ended up being now regarded as junk science. The Innocence Project of Texas presented proof, in addition to state agreed the ladies deserved brand new studies and released the residual three in 2013. By this point, Ramirez was indeed in prison for almost 17 years, while the other two for near to 14. These were all inside their forties that are early.

In 2016, a judge overturned the women’s convictions, deeming a trial that is new. Nonetheless, he said there is proof that is n’t enough declare them innocent. The Court of Criminal Appeals disagreed, as well as in November 2016, declared the ladies “actually innocent.”

This formal exoneration entitled the ladies to settlement from Texas, that will be determined on the basis of the quantity of times served.

By the end of this saga, Esquenazi completed a version that is full-length of documentary and debuted it during the Tribeca Film Festival in 2016. Entitled Southwest of Salem, the movie happens to be crucial in increasing understanding concerning the instance, plus it had been selected for an Emmy and won awards that are numerous including a Peabody honor, the GLAAD Media Award for Outstanding Documentary, therefore the experts Selection Award for Best First Feature. The ladies have actually toured round the global globe, talking around the world about their experience. This launched more possibilities for talking and appearances.

“Deb put it nowadays in ways in which the public could see the facts actually,” Rivera claims. “When we went along to test, individuals simply saw just just what hawaii wished to provide or exactly just exactly what the magazines stated, that was maybe maybe not the important points. There have been therefore lots of people in our community that weren’t really there for us. But after they saw the documentary, people launched their eyes to your injustice.”